Failures of Justice: Lack of Accountability for NATO Forces and Other Insurgent Groups in Afghanistan.
Main Article Content
Abstract
This study critically examines the absence of accountability mechanisms for NATO forces and other insurgent groups during Afghanistan’s two-decade conflict, with particular focus on the disproportionate impact on civilian casualties. Using both qualitative and quantitative methods, it analyses demographic data on civilian casualties and records of U.S. and NATO airstrikes, drawing on reports from international human rights organizations such as UNAMA and Afghan authorities. The findings reveal that, despite coordinated military strategies, U.S. and NATO air operations frequently caused civilian deaths, mass displacement, and long-term socioeconomic disruption. Outcomes varied across troop-contributing nations, reflecting cultural and strategic differences that led to inconsistent application of multinational directives. Demographic analysis further shows that rural provinces bore the greatest burden, with vulnerability and limited access to justice exacerbating the suffering of affected populations. The results suggest that the U.S. invasion post-9/11, rather than improving security, exacerbated Afghanistan’s humanitarian crisis and eroded confidence in global justice mechanisms. The conflict has left enduring consequences for regional stability and international security. The study concludes that accountability for both state and non-state actors remains inadequate and calls for stronger international legal frameworks and culturally informed strategies to prevent similar humanitarian crises.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
References
Council on Foreign Relations, Timeline: The U.S. War in Afghanistan (2022)
The George W. Bush Presidential Library, Address to the Nation on the Terrorist Attacks (20 September 2001)
National Security Archive, Afghanistan 20/20: The 20-Year War in 20 Documents (2021)
United Nations, Agreement on Provisional Arrangements in Afghanistan Pending the Re-establishment of Permanent Government Institutions (Bonn Agreement) (5 December 2001).
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) Key Facts and Figures (2014).
Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm by International Forces in Afghanistan (2014).
NATO, Resolute Support Mission: Key Facts and Figures (2015).
United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA), Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict: Annual Report 2020.
U.S. Department of State, Agreement for Bringing Peace to Afghanistan between the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan and the United States of America (Doha, 29 February 2020).
Congressional Research Service, Afghanistan: Background and U.S. Policy in Brief (2021).
Brown University, Costs of War Project: Human and Budgetary Costs of the Afghanistan War, 2001–2021 (2021).
Centre for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC), Civilian Harm Tracking in Afghanistan: Lessons for Future Operations (2020).
Geneva Convention (I) for the Amelioration of the Condition of the Wounded and Sick in Armed Forces in the Field (adopted 12 August 1949, entered into force 21 October 1950) 75 UNTS 31; Geneva Conventions (II–IV) and Additional Protocols I and II (1977).
Jean-Marie Henckaerts and Louise Doswald-Beck, Customary International Humanitarian Law, Vol I (ICRC/Cambridge University Press 2005)
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Afghanistan: Classification of Conflict and Applicable Law (2018)
Common Article 3, Geneva Conventions (1949); Additional Protocol II (1977), art 4.
UNAMA, Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict: Annual Report 2021 (Kabul, February 2022)
Human Rights Watch, The Air War in Afghanistan: Civilian Casualties and Accountability (2019).
UN Security Council, Report of the Secretary-General on the Situation in Afghanistan (S/2015/942, 10 December 2015).
UNAMA (n 5) 10–12.
Amnesty International, Their Lives on the Line: The Taliban’s Targeting of Civilians (2019).
Abeedullah Aabede, V. Vijay Lakshimi & Nimali Thakshila Withanage, From Ballot to Battlefield and the Erosion of Democratic Governance during the War on Terror in Afghanistan", Journal of Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, Vol. 30, No. 5, pp. 2480–2493 (2024).
World Bank, Afghanistan: Rural Development and Livelihoods Report (2020).
Centre for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC), Civilian Harm Tracking in Afghanistan: Lessons for Future Operations (2020).
Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm by International Forces in Afghanistan (2014).
Human Rights Watch (n 7) 17–19.
UNAMA (n 5) 20.
Mark Osiel, Obeying Orders: Atrocity, Military Discipline and the Law of War (Transaction Publishers 2002).
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976) 999 UNTS 171, art 2(3).
UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), Afghanistan Humanitarian Response Plan 2021(2021).
UNICEF, The Impact of Armed Conflict on Children in Afghanistan (2020).
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (adopted 18 December 1979, entered into force 3 September 1981) 1249 UNTS 13.
Human Rights Watch, The Taliban’s War on Women (2001).
Amnesty International, Afghanistan: Women under the Taliban (1998).
Sima Samar, Human Rights and Women’s Education in Afghanistan (AIHRC Report, 2004).
UNDP, Afghanistan Human Development Report 2007: Bridging Modernity and Tradition (2007).
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan (2004).
United Nations Treaty Collection, Status of CEDAW: Afghanistan (UNTC, 2003).
AIHRC, Annual Report 2005: Human Rights in Afghanistan (2005).
Government of Afghanistan, National Action Plan for the Women of Afghanistan (NAPWA) (2008–2018).
UNICEF, Education under Fire: The State of Girls’ Education in Afghanistan (2021)
Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU), Women in National Parliaments: Afghanistan Profile (2018).
World Bank, Afghanistan Gender Equality Profile (2020).
Oxfam, A Place at the Table: Afghan Women’s Struggle for Peace and Equality (2014).
UN Women, Women, Peace and Security in Afghanistan (2019).
Chandra Talpade Mohanty, ‘Under Western Eyes Revisited: Feminist Solidarity through Anti-capitalist Struggles’ (2003).
UNAMA, Afghanistan: Mid-Year Report on Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict (2019).
Human Rights Watch, You Have No Right to Complain: Education, Social Restrictions, and Justice in Taliban-Held Afghanistan (2020).
U.S. Department of State, Agreement for Bringing Peace to Afghanistan (Doha Agreement) (29 February 2020).
UN Assistance Mission in Afghanistan, Report on Human Rights 2021–2022 (2022).
BBC, ‘Taliban Ban Women from University Education in Afghanistan’ (21 December 2022).
United Nations, Statement by the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Afghanistan (April 2023).
CEDAW (n 1) arts 10–11.
UN General Assembly, Report of the Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Afghanistan, A/78/216 (2023).
Amnesty International, Death in Slow Motion: Women and the Taliban’s Return to Power (2022).
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan (n 6) arts 22–44.
Nadji Al-Ali and Nicola Pratt, What Kind of Liberation? Women and the Occupation of Iraq (University of California Press, 2009)
Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’ in C Nelson and L Grossberg (eds), Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture (Macmillan, 1988).
Government of Afghanistan, Action Plan for Peace, Justice and Reconciliation (2005).
Fionnuala Nattolin, Transitional Justice and Gendered War Crimes. (International Journal of Transitional Justice 2012).
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (adopted 10 December 1948) UNGA Res 217 A (III) art 5; International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976) 999 UNTS 171 art 7; Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (adopted 10 December 1984, entered into force 26 June 1987) 1465 UNTS 85 arts 2 and 16.
Common Article 3, Geneva Conventions (1949); Additional Protocol II (1977).
UNAMA, Treatment of Conflict-Related Detainees in Afghan Custody (2019).
Human Rights Watch, Enduring Freedom: Abuses by U.S. Forces in Afghanistan (2004).
Amnesty International, USA: Human Dignity Denied – Torture and Accountability in the ‘War on Terror’ (2012).
Tim Golden, ‘In U.S. Report, Brutal Details of 2 Afghan Inmates’ Deaths'. (New York Times, 20 May 2005).
Human Rights Watch (n 4) 13.
Ibid. 103–115.Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, Committee Study of the Central Intelligence Agency’s Detention and Interrogation Program (2014)
Manfred Nowak, UN Special Rapporteur on Torture: Interim Report to the General Assembly (A/60/316, 2005).
UNAMA (n 3) 6.
ICCPR (n 1) art 14(3)(g).
Government of Afghanistan, National Plan on the Elimination of Torture (2015).
AIHRC, Annual Report 2018 (2019).
UNAMA (n 3) 12–14.
Canadian Council on Human Rights, Detainee Transfers and Accountability (2013)
R Maya Evans v Secretary of State for Défense [2010] EWCA Civ 1299.
Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm in Afghanistan (2014).
International Criminal Court, Situation in Afghanistan: Report on Preliminary Examination Activities 2020 (2020).
UN General Assembly, Report of the Special Rapporteur on Torture, A/HRC/46/26 (2021).
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Annual Report 2020: Afghanistan Detention Monitoring (2021).
Amnesty International, Afghanistan: Human Rights Under the Taliban (2022).
Government of Afghanistan, Law on Prohibition of Torture (2018).
ICC (n 22) para 230.
U.S. Executive Order 13928, Blocking Property of Certain Persons Associated with the International Criminal Court (11 June 2020).
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan (2004).
AIHRC (n 16) 28.
CAT (n 1) arts 12–14.
UN General Assembly (n 23) para 51.
Louise Arbor, ‘The Responsibility to Protect and the Duty to Prevent’ 40 (NYU Journal of International Law and Politics 687,2008)
UNSC Res 1401 (28 March 2002) UN Doc S/RES/1401.
UNAMA, Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict: Annual Report 2021- 2022).
UNAMA (n 3) 5.
Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm by International Forces in Afghanistan (2014).
NATO, Response to UNAMA Civilian Casualty Reports (2018).
Mark Drumbl, ‘Accountability in Asymmetric Warfare’ (2011) 30 European Journal of International Law 1131.
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan (2004).
AIHRC, Annual Report 2006 (2007).
Government of Afghanistan, Action Plan for Peace, Justice and Reconciliation (2005).
Human Rights Watch, Peace at What Price? Amnesty Law and Accountability in Afghanistan (2010).
National Stability and Reconciliation Law (Official Gazette No 965, 2007).
Amnesty International, Afghanistan: The Fall of the AIHRC and the Silencing of Human Rights Voices (2021).
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (adopted 17 July 1998, entered into force 1 July 2002) 2187 UNTS 3.
ICC, Report on Preliminary Examination Activities 2017 (2017) paras 199–210.
ICC Pre-Trial Chamber II, Decision Authorizing an Investigation into the Situation in Afghanistan (ICC-02/17-33, 5 March 2020).
U.S. Executive Order 13928, Blocking Property of Certain Persons Associated with the ICC (11 June 2020).
Human Rights Watch, US: Investigate Civilian Deaths in Afghanistan (2015).
International Commission of Jurists, Accountability Gap: Military Investigations in the UK and Afghanistan (2021).
Inspector-General of the Australian Défense Force, Afghanistan Inquiry Report (Brereton Report) (2020).
Amnesty International, Unequal Justice: The Failure of National Investigations in Afghanistan (2019).
Government of Afghanistan (n 11).
UNDP, Afghanistan Rule of Law Index (2018).
Oxfam, Rebuilding Justice: Rule of Law in Post-Conflict Afghanistan (2013).
Human Rights Watch (n 12) 19.
Martti Koskenniemi, From Apology to Utopia: The Structure of International Legal Argument (CUP 2005).
UN General Assembly, Report of the Secretary-General on the Rule of Law and Transitional Justice in Conflict and Post-Conflict Societies (A/68/213, 2013).
Mahmood Mamdani, Define and Rule: Native as Political Identity (Harvard University Press, 2012) 96–98.
CIVIC, Civilian Harm and the Erosion of Trust in Afghanistan (2019).
Quoted in Amnesty International (n 14) 5.
ICC Office of the Prosecutor (n 19).
UN Human Rights Council, Resolution 49/1: Situation of Human Rights in Afghanistan (2022).
South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC), Regional Justice Mechanisms in South Asia: Prospects and Challenges (2021).
Operation Enduring Freedom, Encyclopaedia Britannica (2023)
George W. Bush Presidential Library, Address to the Nation on the Terrorist Attacks (20 September 2001)
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), Collective Defence – Article 5 (2022
National Security Archive, Afghanistan 20/20: The 20-Year War in 20 Documents (2021) https://nsarchive.gwu.edu.
United Nations, Agreement on Provisional Arrangements in Afghanistan Pending the Re-Establishment of Permanent Government Institutions (Bonn Agreement) (5 December 2001).
Barnett R Rubin, Afghanistan from the Cold War through the War on Terror (OUP 2013) 252–256.
UNSC Res 1386 (20 December 2001) UN Doc S/RES/1386.
NATO, ISAF: Key Facts and Figures (2014).
NATO, Afghanistan Mission Archive (2015).
David Kilcullen, The Accidental Guerrilla: Fighting Small Wars During a Big One (OUP 2009) 169.
United States Department of Défense, Afghanistan Security Forces Fund Report (2013).
World Bank, Afghanistan Development Update (2016).
NATO, Provincial Reconstruction Teams in Afghanistan (2013).
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Afghanistan: Civilian Protection and the Law of Armed Conflict (2012).
Centre for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC), Civilian Harm Tracking in ISAF (2014) 9–11.
Human Rights Watch, The Air War in Afghanistan: Civilian Casualties and Accountability (2019)
Oxfam, Aid Effectiveness in Conflict Settings: Lessons from Afghanistan (2012).
UNDP, Afghanistan Human Development Report 2011: The Forgotten Fronts (2011).
NATO, Resolute Support Mission: Key Facts and Figures (2015).
U.S. Department of Défense, Report on Enhancing Security and Stability in Afghanistan (2015).
SIGAR (Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction), Quarterly Report to the United States Congress (2018)
SIGAR, Afghan National Défense and Security Forces: Challenges to Effectiveness (2020).
Council on Foreign Relations, Timeline: The U.S. War in Afghanistan (2022).
U.S. Department of State, Agreement for Bringing Peace to Afghanistan between the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan and the United States of America (Doha, 29 February 2020).
NATO, Statement on the Agreement for Peace in Afghanistan (1 March 2020).
NATO, End of the Resolute Support Mission and Withdrawal of Forces (2021).
International Crisis Group, Afghanistan’s Peace Process: A Long Road Ahead (2020).
BBC News, ‘Afghanistan: Taliban Take Control after U.S. Withdrawal’ (16 August 2021).
Council on Foreign Relations (n 24).
Brown University, Costs of War Project: Human and Budgetary Costs of the Afghanistan War 2001–2021 (2021).
Roland Paris, At War’s End: Building Peace after Civil Conflict (CUP 2004) 152–155.
Stephen Biddle, War Termination and the Future of U.S. Strategy in Afghanistan (Foreign Affairs 2013).
Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm by International Forces in Afghanistan (2014).
Encyclopaedia Britannica, Afghanistan War: Civilian Impact and Consequences (2023).
UNAMA, Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict: Annual Report 2021 (2022); Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm by International Forces in Afghanistan (2014).
Brown University, Costs of War Project: Human and Budgetary Costs of the Afghanistan War 2001–2021 (2021).
UNAMA (n 2) 5.
Amnesty International (n 2).
NATO, ISAF Civilian Casualty Tracking Cell: Overview and Implementation (2012).
Centre for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC), Civilian Harm Tracking in ISAF: Understanding and Improving Practice (2014).
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976) 999 UNTS 171 art 2(3).
Government of Afghanistan and United States of America, Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) (2014).
Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 (Protocol I) (adopted 8 June 1977) 1125 UNTS 3 art 48.
Human Rights Watch, The Air War in Afghanistan: Civilian Casualties and Accountability (2019).
The Bureau of Investigative Journalism, Drone Strikes in Afghanistan: Civilian Impact Assessment (2017).
Human Rights Watch (n 13) 9–12.
NATO, Tactical Directive: Minimizing Civilian Casualties in Afghanistan (ISAF HQ, 2009).
U.S. Department of State, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: Afghanistan 2019 (2020).
UNAMA (n 2) 13–15.
Amnesty International, Their Lives on the Line: Targeting of Civilians by the Taliban and IS-KP (2019).
Common Article 3, Geneva Conventions (1949).
CIVIC (n 8) 18.
SOFA (n 10).
UNDP, Afghanistan Rule of Law Index (2018).
Council on Foreign Relations, Accountability and Civilian Protection in Afghanistan (2020).
Amnesty International (n 2) 28.
ICC, Report on Preliminary Examination Activities 2020 (2020).
UNHCR, Afghanistan Displacement Crisis Report (2021).
OCHA, Afghanistan Humanitarian Needs Overview 2021 (2021).
WHO, Mental Health in Emergencies: Afghanistan (2020).
UNICEF, Education under Fire: The State of Schools in Afghanistan (2021).
WHO, Attacks on Health Care in Afghanistan: Annual Report 2020 (2021).
UNAMA, Human Rights in Afghanistan: Annual Report 2020 (2021).
UNAMA, Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict: Annual Report 2021 (2022); Human Rights Watch, The Air War in Afghanistan: Civilian Casualties and Accountability (2019).
Amnesty International, Left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Harm by International Forces in Afghanistan (2014).
Human Rights Watch (n 1) 9.
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (adopted 17 July 1998, entered into force 1 July 2002) 2187 UNTS 3 arts 5–8.
NATO, Status of Forces Agreement Frameworks and National Jurisdictions (2010).
U.S. Department of Justice, Getting Away with Murder? Investigations and Accountability in Afghanistan (2015).
Louise Arbor, The Responsibility to Protect and the Duty to Prevent (2008) 40 NYU Journal of International Law and Politics 687, 703.
Mark Osiel, Obeying Orders: Atrocity, Military Discipline and the Law of War (Transaction 2002) 289.
National Security Archive, Afghanistan 20/20: The 20-Year War in 20 Documents (2021) https://nsarchive.gwu.edu.
NATO, ISAF Rules of Engagement and National Caveats (2012).
CIVIC, Civilian Harm Tracking in ISAF: Understanding and Improving Practice (2014).
National Security Archive (n 9).
UNDP, Afghanistan Rule of Law Index (2018) 6–9.
SIGAR, Quarterly Report to the United States Congress (2019).
Government of Afghanistan and United States of America, Status of Forces Agreement (2014)
Amnesty International (n 2) 18.
Human Rights Watch, ‘Afghanistan: Accountability for Panjwai Massacre’ (2012).
UNAMA, Afghanistan: Protection of Civilians Midyear Update 2020 (2020).
Amnesty International, Their Lives on the Line: Taliban and IS-KP Targeting of Civilians (2019).
ICC, Report on Preliminary Examination Activities 2020 (2020) paras 214–230.
Amnesty International, Afghanistan: Human Rights Under the Taliban (2022).
NATO, Lessons Learned from ISAF Operations (2015).
International Commission of Jurists, Accountability Gap: Military Investigations in the UK and Afghanistan (2021).
Inspector-General of the Australian Défense Force, Afghanistan Inquiry Report (Brereton Report) (2020).
William Schabas, An Introduction to the International Criminal Court (6th end, CUP 2020) 403–406.
United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA), Afghanistan: Annual Report on Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict (2009–2021); Brown University, Watson Institute, Costs of War Project: Afghan Civilians (updated datasets); Amnesty International, Afghanistan: Civilian Casualties Report (various years).
Neta C. Crawford, Update on the Human Costs of War in Afghanistan (Brown University, Costs of War Project, 2021); UNAMA, Protection of Civilians Midyear Report 2020 (noting patterns linked to changes in ROE and targeting policies).
Amnesty International, left in the Dark: Failures of Accountability for Civilian Casualties Caused by International Military Operations in Afghanistan (2014); Doctors Without Borders (MSF), MSF Kunduz Trauma Centre Attack Investigation (2015); United States Department of Défense, Report on the Panjwai Massacre (2012).
NATO, International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) Mission Mandate (2001–2014); UNSC Resolution 1386, UN Doc. S/RES/1386 (Dec. 20, 2001) (authorizing ISAF).
NATO Parliamentary Assembly, Civilian Casualties and ISAF Operations in Afghanistan (Report No. 165 CDS 11 E rev. 1, 2011) (describing decentralized ROE practices).
Theo Farrell, Unwinnable: Britain's War in Afghanistan, 2001–2014 (London: Bodley Head, 2017); Christian Dennys, Military Culture and Civilian Harm in Afghanistan (Chatham House Working Paper, 2013).
NATO Standardization Office, NATO Standardization Agreements (STANAGs), esp. STANAG 2044 (Rules of Engagement) and STANAG 2294 (Handling Civilian Casualties).
Charli Carpenter, Lost Causes, Constructing and Contesting Civilian Victimhood (Cornell Univ. Press 2020).
UK Ministry of Defense, Iraq and Afghanistan Fatality Investigations (2010–2020); Bundeswehr, Parliamentary Oversight and Accountability Mechanisms (German Federal
Richard Bennett, UNAMA and Civilian Protection: Gaps in Accountability Mechanisms (UNAMA Human Rights Unit Briefing, 2018)
David Pugliese, Canada in Afghanistan: The Reluctant Combatant (Canadian Defense & Foreign Affairs Institute, 2015); Christian Dennys, Understanding Military Cultures in NATO (Chatham House, 2013).
UK Civil-Military Cooperation Group (CIMIC), Field Handbook (2012); German Federal Ministry of Defense, Stabilization Strategy and Civil-Military Guidelines (2010).
Larry Lewis & Sarah Holewinski, Reducing and Mitigating Civilian Harm in Afghanistan: Lessons from the Field (Centre for Civilians in Conflict & Joint Centre for Operational Analysis, 2013); Peter Bergen & Katherine Tiedemann, The Drone War in Afghanistan and Pakistan (New America Foundation, 2010).f..